Download Our FREE 4-Character Version of Bullets on Broadway!

Become a party legend by throwing a Murder Mystery party for your next office event, game night, birthday, or gathering! Make memories with this ready-to-play printable kit.

Virtual rules are included to play on Zoom!

The Story

It’s opening night of Murder in the First on Broadway, and nerves are high. The cast and crew are all a buzz backstage with the excitement of the lights, the sounds - and the dead body of big-shot Broadway Producer. There lies Jack Bialystock, shot in the back center stage before the curtain could rise. Was the murderer a cast member, like Anita Part who’s making her Broadway debut tonight, or seasoned performer Sienna Stealer? Was it the snooty theatre critic Bob Blandley, or a member of the audience like Megan Phan who somehow wandered backstage?
There’s only one way to find out: play the game Bullets on Broadway! But hold onto your overpriced wine—the murderer may be YOU!

Sign up with your email address to receive a FREE digital download of the 4-character version of Bullets on Broadway!

“This is the best thing to happen to me during quarantine. So FUN!”

— Jackie D.

What’s Included

Character Packets

This downloadable murder mystery includes 20 character packets. Each character has information about themselves that they can reveal, information that is for their eyes only, an introduction and info on their whereabouts at the time of the murder, answers to questions each round, and final statements for innocent and guilty game plays.

Who Did It Slips

Who Did It Slips help assign the murderer each time the game is played, as well as assign the order in which each innocent player makes their final statements.

Questions Menu

The 12-page Question menu provides questions to ask each character for each of the three rounds of the game. Every character has juicy information to reveal, and ANYONE could be the murderer!

Award Certificates

Award Certificates are provided for Best Actor, Best Actress, Best Costume, Best Accent, and Best Improv in a Murder Mystery. Simply print the certificates and write their names!

Host Guide

The Host Guide is 6 pages of information on how to host your murder mystery party, as well as detailed information on exactly how to play the game. The host should use this guide throughout the party to ensure that the story, evidence, and narration progresses according to plan. Virtual Host Guide Included!

Guest Invitations

Invitations are provided for you to send each guest. They include information for each character, including costume suggestions, as well as space to provide important details about your party, like the date, time, and location.

And more!

The Characters

The mystery is built to be played by 4-20 characters, ANY of whom could be the murderer and each have gripping motives for murder. There are 8 women and 12 men, but many can be played by any gender.

Idina Mental

Sexy and sultry, Idina’s the leading lady everyone dreams of and she knows it. Her long gown and ruby red lips are enough to make any man kill.

Billy Bergamont

Billy is a dashing young playwright with wit and charm...maybe too much for his own good.

Julie Tamenomore

Julie is the Director, an artistic and creative soul with a dark secret.

Bob Blandley

Bob is a dry and dull theatre critic whose husband’s shopping addiction is getting in the way of his work.

Audrey Torium

Audrey is a mousy and meek Usher with a timid demeanor...or so she likes people to think.

Anita Part

Anita is a young actress fresh to New York City. She’s green, wide eyed, and overly enthusiastic…with a secret past.

Robert Whineman

Robert is a greasy sleeze ball talent agent with slicked back hair and a black eye.

Matthew Broadneck

Matthew’s the leading man, a bit past his prime, with something to prove.

Kaitlyn Chinnoweth

Kaitlyn is a busty blonde actress who likes to show skin and get attention...and sometimes she catches the wrong eye.

Sam Rubin

Sam is a bitter Producer and here for business, nothing more.

Megan Phan

Megan Phan is a fan who traveled to New York just for this opening night performance, and the hope that she could get Idina’s autograph…and maybe more.

Trip Fallington

Trip is the trap door operator and a tough guy with tattoos and a record.

Roy Floosey

Roy is an investor in the show and is dressed in an ill fitting suit and dirty old shoes.

Ivana Cut

Ivana is Idina Mental’s agent and will do anything to get her commission check...even if it means making a killer deal.

Sienna Stealer

Sienna is an actress in the show. She’s a loose cannon and always drunk or hopped up on something.

Colin Back

Colin is a well known Casting Director with a sleazy personality. He’s overly flirtatious and it gets him in trouble.

William Mundy

William is an old friend, partner, and most trusted confidant of the deceased.

Lue Jackman

Lue is a flamboyant, over the top, character actor dressed in brightly colored clothes. He’s clearly overcompensating for some deeply held secret.

Franky Stub

Franky is a meek and nervous Box Office boy who’s always late for work. He has a pimple face, bowl cut hair and he’s got a stutter.

Bobby Straum

Bobby is a ruggedly handsome guitar player with a man bun...and a grudge.

“I’ve played a lot of murder mystery games and this was by far the most fun. PERFECT for theater fans.”

— Michelle L.

The Evidence Narration

The Detective Narration below is a sample of the Introduction narration provided to players. The full series of videos is to be used during the “Evidence” sections while playing the game.


How many people can play?

This murder mystery party is designed to be played by 4-20 people. ALL 20 roles have full motives and ANY of the characters could be the murderer.

How do you play?

Great question. You can read a thorough rundown of how to play here.

Can I play virtually via video chat?

You bet! We created a whole new set of rules and instructions to be able to play via video chat, including how best to assign the murderer so that the host does not know who it is.

What do I actually get when I buy this?

You will receive all the files needed to host and run your murder mystery party as a digital download. You’ll then be able to easily print the files and play as many times as you like! You will also receive a link to the “Evidence” video narrated by a Broadway actress.

Can you play more than once?

Absolutely! We’ve created this game to be played over and over again, because the murderer always changes! Use your “Who Did It Slips” to assign a new murderer each time you play! Plus, the answers to the questions each round are different based on whether or not the character is guilty!

What ages is this appropriate for?

This murder mystery party game is appropriate for ages 13+.

How do I buy this murder mystery game with al 20 characters?

So happy you want to play! Click here to be taken to our secure checkout order form! Upon payment you will be redirected to a page where you can download your materials as well as receive them by email.

Translation missing: