7 Signs Your Friends Would Be Terrible Murder Mystery Suspects
One of the best parts of hosting a murder mystery party is discovering what your friends are really like when a crime needs solving.
Some people become brilliant detectives.
Others? Well... let's just say they'd be arrested before dessert.
Here are 7 signs your friends would make terrible murder mystery suspects.
1. They Can't Keep a Secret
Every murder mystery character has secrets.
If your friend starts every sentence with, "Okay, but don't tell anyone..." and then immediately reveals everything, they're not surviving the first round of questioning.
2. They Laugh at the Worst Possible Times
The detective asks where they were when the victim was murdered.
They start laughing.
Instantly suspicious.
Even if they're completely innocent, everyone at the party will vote for them.
3. They Forget Their Own Story
Five minutes ago they were in the library.
Now they claim they were on a yacht.
By the end of the night, nobody—including them—knows what their alibi is anymore.
4. They Accuse Everyone
Some players carefully gather clues.
Others walk into the room and immediately accuse six people before appetizers are served.
Confidence is impressive. Accuracy is optional.
5. They Love Being Dramatic
Every murder mystery group has at least one person who treats a simple question like a Broadway audition.
Are they guilty?
Maybe not.
But they're definitely making things more entertaining.
6. They Trust Nobody
Every clue is a conspiracy.
Every suspect is lying.
Every innocent comment is somehow connected to the crime.
These players may never solve the mystery, but they'll create plenty of new ones.
7. They Somehow Become the Prime Suspect Every Time
You know the friend.
They didn't do it.
Probably.
But somehow the evidence, the rumors, and the group vote always point directly at them.
It's almost a tradition at this point.
The Truth?
The most memorable murder mystery parties aren't about finding the perfect detective.
They're about laughing, making accusations, uncovering secrets, and creating stories your group will talk about long after the killer is revealed.
Ready to put your friends to the test?
Browse our collection of murder mystery party games here and discover why thousands of hosts choose Broadway Murder Mysteries to bring their parties to life!
Search
Recent Post
Archive
- June 2026
- April 2026
- February 2026
Quick Links
Let's Get the Party Started!
Submit an inquiry via the form below and our expert murder mystery party planner will be in touch shortly to assist with the details of your private murder mystery event.
Broadway Murder Mysteries, where YOU are the show! Broadway Murder Mysteries was created in March of 2020 when many Broadway performers, writers, and talent were out of work. The Broadway shut down had a huge impact on the theater community, and Broadway Murder Mysteries was created to give jobs to out of work talent, while creating something inherently theatrical that theater and mystery fans would love. All our murder mystery party games have been created by Broadway talent. Host a murder mystery party or murder mystery game night today!
Added to cart successfully!
FROM_JS
jsprice
jsprice
FROM_JS
FROM_JS
Add to cart
Added
Limit Products
Wait..
Translation missing: en.general.search.loading
x